What Is the Difference Between Alkaline & Non-Alkaline Batteries?

By Timothy Boyer
Physically, an alkaline and a non-alkaline battery look identical.

Non-rechargeable, dry cell batteries are categorized in several ways: by letter designations, by voltages and by applications. However, a chemical classification that differentiates dry cell batteries is whether a battery is alkaline or non-alkaline, or, more accurately, whether its electrolyte is a base or an acid. This distinction differentiates both chemically and performance-wise the differences between alkaline and non-alkaline batteries.

Battery Basics

A battery is an electrochemical cell where chemical energy is converted into electrical energy. A typical dry cell battery consists of a positively charged anode, a negatively charged cathode and an electrolyte that reacts with the anode and cathode during an electrochemical reaction called an oxidation-reduction reaction.The anode tends to lose electrodes -- is oxidized -- whereas the cathode tends to gain electrons, or is reduced. A surplus of electrons at the negative cathode -- negative battery terminal -- and a deficit of electrons at the positive anode -- positive battery terminal -- creates an electrical pressure called voltage. When a battery is placed in a circuit, electrons flow as current between the cathode and the anode doing useful electrical work. The battery then recharges itself with additional oxidation-reduction reactions until the anode and cathode are eventually chemically depleted, resulting in a dead battery.

Electrolyte Basics

The ability of acids and bases to dissociate into free ions makes them good battery electrolytes.

An electrolyte is a substance that contains free ions that are electrically conductive. An example of an electrolyte is common table salt consisting of positive charged potassium and negative charged chloride ions. A battery electrolyte is an acid or a base that dissociates into positive and negative charged ions that react with the anode and cathode as a battery undergoes an oxidation-reduction reaction.

Alkaline Battery

Chemically, a typical alkaline dry cell battery has a zinc anode and a manganese dioxide cathode. The electrolyte is a non-acidic basic paste. A typical electrolyte used in alkaline batteries is potassium hydroxide. Physically, a typical alkaline battery consists of a steel can packed with manganese dioxide in its outermost internal cathode region and is filled with zinc and the electrolyte within the center-most internal anode region. The electrolyte surrounding the anode mediates the chemical reaction between the anode and the cathode.

Non-Alkaline Battery

Chemically, a typical non-alkaline dry cell battery has a zinc anode and a carbon rod/manganese dioxide cathode. The electrolyte is typically an acidic paste. A typical electrolyte used consists of a mixture of ammonium chloride and zinc chloride. Physically, a typical non-alkaline battery is constructed the reverse of an alkaline battery. The zinc container serves as an outer anode whereas the carbon rod/manganese dioxide occupies the inner region as the cathode. The electrolyte is mixed with the cathode and mediates the chemical reaction between the cathode and the anode.

The Better Battery?

The overall consensus is that chemically, the alkaline battery has a slight performance edge over a non-alkaline battery. However, non-alkaline batteries are dependable, less expensive and interchangeable with alkaline battery use. Electronic devices that carry a label stating "Use alkaline batteries only" are typically warranted under conditions where a quick, high-current draw is needed from a battery. One example of this would be a flash unit on a camera where a fast recharge is desired.

About the Author

Since 1999, Timothy Boyer has worked as a freelance writer. His career began as a science columnist with "The Northwest Explorer" and as a science writer with McGraw-Hill publishing's Power Web Series of educational articles. Boyer has a Ph.D. in molecular and cellular biology from the University of Arizona.