The Disadvantages of a Potentiometer

••• amplifier knobs image by Darko Draskovic from Fotolia.com

Potentiometers, or pots, are adjustable resistors having a contact that moves across a resistive element. Some have a rotary action, and others are linear. This motion involves friction between internal parts, and leads to wear and noise. While designers use pots as inexpensive, easy-to-use electronic controls, wear and inertia limit their usefulness as sensors in mechanical systems. Over decades, potentiometer materials have improved, but these fundamental problems still exist.

Wear

Most potentiometers last only a few thousand rotations before the materials wear out. Although this may sound like a lot, and may mean years of service in some applications, it takes special designs to stand up to daily, demanding use. And it means they can’t be used for machine sensing where rapid cycling would wear them out in a matter of minutes.

Noise

The action of the wiper moving across the element creates a noise called "fader scratch." In new pots, this noise is inaudible, but it can get worse with age. Dust and wear increase the bumpiness of the action and make the noise noticeable. Small cracks can appear in the element, and these make noise as the wiper moves over them.

In addition to these mechanically caused noises, carbon elements, in particular, are prone to producing electrical noise. This noise is heard as a soft, steady hiss that can degrade sound recordings. The resistive materials have improved over the years, so newer pots are quieter than their ancestors.

Inertia

The friction between the potentiometer’s wiper and resistive element creates a drag or inertia that the pot must overcome before it turns. Although this drag is not large, it prevents the pot from being used as a rotary sensor in more sensitive applications.

Limited Power

Out of necessity, most potentiometers can dissipate only a few watts of power at most. To handle more power, they would have to be larger and more expensive. Engineers work around this problem by putting the potentiometer in low-power parts of circuits. They control small currents, which, in turn, control transistors and other components with greater power ratings.

References

About the Author

Chicago native John Papiewski has a physics degree and has been writing since 1991. He has contributed to "Foresight Update," a nanotechnology newsletter from the Foresight Institute. He also contributed to the book, "Nanotechnology: Molecular Speculations on Global Abundance." Please, no workplace calls/emails!

Photo Credits

  • amplifier knobs image by Darko Draskovic from Fotolia.com

Dont Go!

We Have More Great Sciencing Articles!