Electronic Ballasts vs. Magnetic Ballasts

••• fluorescent bulb image by Albert Lozano from <a href='http://www.fotolia.com'>Fotolia.com</a>

Fluorescent light bulbs use an arc of electricity to create light. This current must be applied in very precise ways to the gases within the bulb--normal household electrical current is too erratic and powerful for the fluorescent bulb. So the bulb comes with a control device known as the ballast, which limits the current and meters it out in cycles that the bulb needs to keep lit. There are two kinds of ballasts, the newer electric versions and the older magnetic versions.

Electronic Ballasts

Electronic ballasts use circuits to control the flow of current. These use a magnetic output transformer, an EMI filter, a rectifier and integrated circuitry to manage the flow of current very precisely. These ballasts are smaller and lighter than magnetic versions.

Magnetic Ballasts

Magnetic ballasts are older devices that use a magnetic transformer made of a steel core and copper windings, along with a simple bi-metal switch for thermal protection and a simple capacitor. They are larger and heavier than electric ballasts.

Efficiency

Electric ballasts can control the current flow more efficiently than magnetic versions. Magnetic versions can only maintain a current of around 60 hertz, which can cause flickering in the bulb. Electric ballasts can double that to 120 hertz, making more efficient use of the power provided and avoiding any problems associated with flickering fluorescent light. This makes electric ballasts more popular in homes.

Costs

Magnetic ballasts tend to be much easier to make than electric ballasts, so they have lower costs. These low costs can be attractive to buyers who must supply ballast for a large number of fluorescent bulbs, but it comes with a cost. Magnetic ballasts also need to be replaced more often than electric versions, offsetting the upfront cost savings that buyers can make.

Applications

Magnetic ballasts do well with traditional, long-tube fluorescent lights used for everyday applications. However, fluorescent lights that dim, or compact fluorescent lights, often require electric ballasts. Magnetic ballasts simply do not have the capability to control current in specific ways necessary to dim a bulb or provide power to multiple bulbs at one time. The more complicated the application, the better the electric ballast will be.

References

About the Author

Tyler Lacoma has worked as a writer and editor for several years after graduating from George Fox University with a degree in business management and writing/literature. He works on business and technology topics for clients such as Obsessable, EBSCO, Drop.io, The TAC Group, Anaxos, Dynamic Page Solutions and others, specializing in ecology, marketing and modern trends.

Photo Credits

  • fluorescent bulb image by Albert Lozano from Fotolia.com

Dont Go!

We Have More Great Sciencing Articles!