Science Projects to Learn if an Ice Cube Melts Faster in Air or Water

••• Ice cube image by vidak from

Understanding the states of matter is one of the fundamentals skills required to advance a student's comprehension of the material sciences. For this reason, it is valuable to direct students to understand the way phase change takes place in matter. Science projects with melting ice are a useful first-tier experiment for the novice student. Examining how air and water affect how ice melts is a useful basis for such experimentation.

Control Experiments

These kind of projects are designed with the "all things being equal" principle, and with the idea of creating a baseline for further exploration. One of the best control projects for determining melting speeds in air and water involves placing a single ice cube onto a wooden coaster and another into a glass of water that has been allowed to equalize to room temperature. Both cubes should be stored in similar areas with no ambient exposure to air currents, heat sources or bright lights and monitored until the ice is gone.

Air Variable Projects

These projects rely on a clear control experiment as a baseline to see how changes in the air affect the outcome of the melting. The experiment should maintain the same initial parameters as the control experiment, with modifications to the air component. Students should use fans to blow heated or non-heated air over both cubes (at various speed settings), and then note any changes to the total melting time for the ice cubes.

Water Variable Projects

These projects, like the air variable projects, require a clear baseline control value. However, in these experiments, the only variables are in the water medium used. Varying amounts of salt, vinegar and other substances are added to the water to see if the dissolved materials affect the melting speed of the ice. You can also vary the starting temperature of the water to see how this changes the results.

Ice Variable Experiments

In these experiments, you will use the same baseline values for each element, except for varying the the way the ice is used. In one variant of this project, you can vary the number of cubes used and see how this alters the melting time. In another, you can use larger ice cubes, or even ice cubes of varying shapes. In yet another, you can arrange the cubes into differing shapes to see how they affect melting speeds.


About the Author

Andy Klaus started his writing career contributing science and fiction articles to Dickinson High School's newsletters back in 1984. Since then, he has authored novels and written technical books for health-care companies such as VersaSuite. He has covered topics varying from aerospace to zoology and received an associate degree in science from College of the Mainland.

Photo Credits